The Scandalous Hamiltons: A Gilded Age Grifter, a Founding Father's Disgraced Descendant, and a Trial at the Dawn of Tabloid Journalism

The Scandalous Hamiltons: A Gilded Age Grifter, a Founding Father's Disgraced Descendant, and a Trial at the Dawn of Tabloid Journalism

  • Downloads:1284
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2022-08-18 17:21:35
  • Update Date:2025-09-06
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Bill Shaffer
  • ISBN:B09KP29JG9
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

An Alexander Hamilton heir, a beautiful female con artist, an abandoned baby, and the shocking courtroom drama that was splashed across front pages from coast to coast--this is the fascinating true story behind one of the greatest scandals of the Gilded Age, and the story that gave rise to the sensational tabloid journalism still driving so much of the news cycle in the 21st century。

It's a story almost too tawdry to be true--a con woman prostitute who met the descendant of a Founding Father in a brothel, duped him into marriage using an infant purchased from a baby farm, then went to prison for stabbing the couple's baby nurse--all while in a common-law marriage with another man。 The scandal surrounding Evangeline and Robert Ray Hamilton, though little known today, was one of the sensations of the Gilded Age, a sordid, gripping tale involving bigamy, bribery, sex, and violence。

When the salacious Hamilton story emerged in during Eva's trial for the August 1889 stabbing, it commanded unprecedented national and international newspaper coverage thanks to the telegraph and the recently founded Associated Press。 For the New York dailies, eager to capture readers through provocative headlines, Ray and Eva were a godsend。

As lurid details emerged, the public's fascination grew--how did a man of Hamilton's stature become entangled with such an adventuress? Nellie Bly, the world-famous investigative reporter, finagled an exclusive interview with Eva after her conviction。 Hamilton's death under mysterious circumstances, a year after the stabbing, added to the intrigue。

Through personal correspondence, court records, and sensational newspaper accounts, The Scandalous Hamiltons explores not only the full, riveting saga of ill-fated Ray and Eva, but the rise of tabloid journalism and celebrity in a story that is both a fascinating slice of pop culture history and a timeless tale of ambition, greed, and obsession。

Download

Reviews

Arithe Kline

I wanted to like this book more than I did。 I have watched the musical Hamilton and have read other books about Alexander Hamilton, and I was excited to read about this descendant with his own compelling story。 However, while his story is fascinating, I feel like the story could have been told better。 It seemed like the story jumped right in to the action with not much back story or build-up。 Then, it seemed like much of the "action" was over and not enough story left to tell。 As incredible as t I wanted to like this book more than I did。 I have watched the musical Hamilton and have read other books about Alexander Hamilton, and I was excited to read about this descendant with his own compelling story。 However, while his story is fascinating, I feel like the story could have been told better。 It seemed like the story jumped right in to the action with not much back story or build-up。 Then, it seemed like much of the "action" was over and not enough story left to tell。 As incredible as the story of Robert Ray Hamilton's short life was (as was that of Eva Steele/Mann/Hamilton/Gaul/Whoever), at times I felt myself bored with the story telling。Disclaimer: I won a free copy of the book through Goodreads。 This is my honest opinion。 。。。more

Tina Dahm

Interesting but not enough for a book。

NonFiction 24/7

I like history but I don't like celebrity gossip。 I found this to be more gossip and the book to slow moving to get me interested。 DNF I like history but I don't like celebrity gossip。 I found this to be more gossip and the book to slow moving to get me interested。 DNF 。。。more

Betty

I received a free ARC of this book through the Goodreads Giveaway program in exchange for my honest opinion。I had never heard about these members of the Hamilton family and was therefore intrigued to find out more。 The writing of this book ambled along at a very leisurely pace and it seemed to include a lot of characters that were not that important to the story line。The scenes in the courtrooms reminded me a lot of the way "Law and Order" is in on TV。。。。。 that was the most interesting part。 I received a free ARC of this book through the Goodreads Giveaway program in exchange for my honest opinion。I had never heard about these members of the Hamilton family and was therefore intrigued to find out more。 The writing of this book ambled along at a very leisurely pace and it seemed to include a lot of characters that were not that important to the story line。The scenes in the courtrooms reminded me a lot of the way "Law and Order" is in on TV。。。。。 that was the most interesting part。 。。。more

Kelly

I have been really enjoying historical true crime, and this was an excellent book。 Robert Ray Hamilton, who came from an illustrious family, ends up splashed across tabloids around the world when his wife Evangeline is put on trial for stabbing their baby’s nurse。 This book deals not only with the event that caused such salacious headlines, but also with what happened to the couple and their child after。 It was really interesting learning how a man who had everything had fallen for the charms of I have been really enjoying historical true crime, and this was an excellent book。 Robert Ray Hamilton, who came from an illustrious family, ends up splashed across tabloids around the world when his wife Evangeline is put on trial for stabbing their baby’s nurse。 This book deals not only with the event that caused such salacious headlines, but also with what happened to the couple and their child after。 It was really interesting learning how a man who had everything had fallen for the charms of a woman who saw an opportunity to better herself and took it with both hands。 I also thought that the book provided a good “slice of life”, giving a glimpse of how people existed in the late 1800s。 I enjoyed the narrator of the audiobook。 He had a lovely, well modulated voice and a good pace。 I’m not particularly skilled at listening to audio, so I definitely appreciate an easy listening narrator。 I also liked the different inflections he put on for the voices and he was consistent with how he read Evangeline’s words in particular, giving a feminine impression without resorting to verbal caricatures。 A cross over book which is likely to interest people who read true crime and history。 。。。more

Jada

Thank you to NetGalley and Bill Shaffer for this ARC in exchange for my honest feedback and review。 Before I read this book I had not heard of Robert Ray Hamilton。 This tawdry story of lies, sex, deceit was very interesting。 If you have an interest in history especially those lesser known historical figures of famous families this is the read for you! I would love to learn more about the Hamilton family now。

George

I bought the book thinking it would be an interesting story about a scandal from the late 19th century。 And while it was interesting, the scandal and trial were about half the book。 The rest of it was just gossipy and boring。

Nae

And we thought these internet days were full of scandal 。。。 this book is a roller coaster ride, prostitute marries wealthy man, buys 3 different babies (2 of whom dies) to pawn off as his child 。。。 and it just gets more complicated from there :)

James Freeman

So scandalous!

Mary Berger

Enjoyed this before unheard of story。 It is surprising how history seems to always repeat itself when it comes to money。 Still surprising what lengths some people will go to get it。

Helen Carolan

An excellent look at a gilded age scandal。 When Robert Ray Hamilton, a descendant of the great Alexander Hamilton and a scion of the upper classes met Eva Mann in a brothel, the pair began an affair。 After four years Eva a con woman of some repute, despaired of landing her catch and convinced Hamilton she was pregnant with their child。 Months after the birth the pair eloped and married in secret。 Soon the marriage was in trouble and Eva was on trial for stabbing their wet nurse。 Sentenced to two An excellent look at a gilded age scandal。 When Robert Ray Hamilton, a descendant of the great Alexander Hamilton and a scion of the upper classes met Eva Mann in a brothel, the pair began an affair。 After four years Eva a con woman of some repute, despaired of landing her catch and convinced Hamilton she was pregnant with their child。 Months after the birth the pair eloped and married in secret。 Soon the marriage was in trouble and Eva was on trial for stabbing their wet nurse。 Sentenced to two years in prison, Hamilton began divorce proceedings but died before they fully began。 Eva launched a bid to clam some of his estate。 Soon mud-slinging ensued on both sides as each tried to prove they were in the right。 This fascinating book looks at the build up to both trials and the many lives Eva led afterwards。 。。。more

B。

I won a copy of this one in a Goodreads Giveaway。 The book was a bit dry in the presentation of material, but other than that, it's your pretty standard history。 Given the title, I expected a bit more salaciousness, or a conversational tone at the least on the part of the author - something to make it less dry。 It seems as though the author wanted to capitalize on the success of Hamilton and did so by writing about a random heir in hopes that would drive sales。 Unfortunately, this one didn't liv I won a copy of this one in a Goodreads Giveaway。 The book was a bit dry in the presentation of material, but other than that, it's your pretty standard history。 Given the title, I expected a bit more salaciousness, or a conversational tone at the least on the part of the author - something to make it less dry。 It seems as though the author wanted to capitalize on the success of Hamilton and did so by writing about a random heir in hopes that would drive sales。 Unfortunately, this one didn't live up to its promise for me。 。。。more

Aimee

Well, this was a book that was engaging and some of the horrific practices of baby farms and buying of infants in the Victorian Era。 The author points out that babies in a baby farm were at least alive and not murdered right after they were born。 Apparently, they had no qualms about killing an infant if they were that much in dire straits。 Anyway, I’ll sum it up to say that this book was interesting and shines a light on the fact that Nellie Bly, one of the first female newspaper reports was the Well, this was a book that was engaging and some of the horrific practices of baby farms and buying of infants in the Victorian Era。 The author points out that babies in a baby farm were at least alive and not murdered right after they were born。 Apparently, they had no qualms about killing an infant if they were that much in dire straits。 Anyway, I’ll sum it up to say that this book was interesting and shines a light on the fact that Nellie Bly, one of the first female newspaper reports was the first one do so an undercover investigation and expose。 That’s pretty awesome。 Worth a read if you like history and the Hamilton family are intriguing to you。 The great grandson of Alexander Hamilton, he’s the focus。 。。。more

Nick Graziano & Pat Graziano

Must readI liked the authenticity of the places visited like Jackson hole wy。 New York's different hotels and Restaurants that took place over a hundred years ago it reallytweeted the imagination this book rates right up their with honey I will be right there after this chapter not to mention this women he married if true ! What a piece of work she was。 Well good luck with the book my wife is going to read it next I know she will love it。 Must readI liked the authenticity of the places visited like Jackson hole wy。 New York's different hotels and Restaurants that took place over a hundred years ago it reallytweeted the imagination this book rates right up their with honey I will be right there after this chapter not to mention this women he married if true ! What a piece of work she was。 Well good luck with the book my wife is going to read it next I know she will love it。 。。。more

Pooja Peravali

When Ray Hamilton’s wife is arrested for stabbing the family’s wet nurse, a great deal of scandalous truth comes out – namely, that the child is not his, nor hers。I have not seen that seminal musical Hamilton, but I had read the doorstopper of a book it was based on。 While I knew all about the successes and scandals of Alexander Hamilton’s life, I had not considered his descendants。 This descendant in particular had rather fewer successes and rather more scandals。The star of the show, though, is When Ray Hamilton’s wife is arrested for stabbing the family’s wet nurse, a great deal of scandalous truth comes out – namely, that the child is not his, nor hers。I have not seen that seminal musical Hamilton, but I had read the doorstopper of a book it was based on。 While I knew all about the successes and scandals of Alexander Hamilton’s life, I had not considered his descendants。 This descendant in particular had rather fewer successes and rather more scandals。The star of the show, though, is Eva – Hamilton? Mann? – his wife。 A grifter of the highest order, she is simultaneously infuriating and sympathetic。 After all, what can a woman be but out for herself? The parts of the book that involve her are the most compelling, though in general the first half of the book was very engaging。However, I did think the story began to drift a little in the second half as the scandal becomes mostly played out, and the author apparently scoured the newspapers for tidbits of news to keep the story going。 He has a fascinating story to tell, but I wonder if the book wouldn’t have been better served by not plunging straight into the action, and instead writing a bit more about the lead up to the scandal first。Disclaimer: I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley。 This is my honest and voluntary review。 。。。more

Kim

An interesting look at a scandal amid the scandalous Gilded Age, featuring the great-grandson of one of the premier Founding Couples, Alexander and Elizabeth Hamilton and a scheming fortune hunter, all culminating in a story so full of twists and turns that it will make your head spin, all told under the shadow of the first of what we today call tabloid journalists。

Zachary

A book inspired by a fountain。 I'm not sure what I was expecting from this story when I started the book, but it is crazy story with lots of unexpected twists。 A book inspired by a fountain。 I'm not sure what I was expecting from this story when I started the book, but it is crazy story with lots of unexpected twists。 。。。more

Kelly

You’d have to be living under a rock if you don’t know about the rise and fall of Alexander Hamilton but, did you know his Great-Grandson Robert Ray Hamilton lived an equally salacious life? Yeah, me either, which is why you NEED to grab this book。 It is like watching E! or TMZ circa 1870s。 I seriously could not put this book down because it just was almost too much to believe。 Unlike his wordy and bold great-grandfather, Robert Ray Hamilton wanted to live a quiet life, but he got involved with You’d have to be living under a rock if you don’t know about the rise and fall of Alexander Hamilton but, did you know his Great-Grandson Robert Ray Hamilton lived an equally salacious life? Yeah, me either, which is why you NEED to grab this book。 It is like watching E! or TMZ circa 1870s。 I seriously could not put this book down because it just was almost too much to believe。 Unlike his wordy and bold great-grandfather, Robert Ray Hamilton wanted to live a quiet life, but he got involved with a con artist/prostitute (sound familiar) and his once quiet life became front pages news over and over and over again。Thank you to the author for introducing me to a new member of the Hamilton family, this thoroughly researched and well written book kept me enthralled during a portion of a 12。5 hour bus ride to running camp。 I read this book as part of a tour and was gifted the copy to review。 。。。more

Lisa

This is a fascinating and well-researched story of a privileged son of The Gilded Age and a girl 'from the wrong side of the tracks'。 Robert Ray was descended from Alexander Hamilton himself and had a wealthy, educated background。 He was very bright。 After he paid a few dollars for the prostitute Evangeline Steele in New York, he was in for a terrible shock, and the start of a descent from grace。 They married a few years later after she told him that she was pregnant, but they soon began fightin This is a fascinating and well-researched story of a privileged son of The Gilded Age and a girl 'from the wrong side of the tracks'。 Robert Ray was descended from Alexander Hamilton himself and had a wealthy, educated background。 He was very bright。 After he paid a few dollars for the prostitute Evangeline Steele in New York, he was in for a terrible shock, and the start of a descent from grace。 They married a few years later after she told him that she was pregnant, but they soon began fighting。 When Evangeline attacked the baby's nurse with a knife, Robert found himself forced to face the trial of a century, and discovered that what Evangeline had told him was a pack of lies, and even more scandals lay ahead。。。I enjoyed this, but not as much as reading about the endlessly interesting Alexander。I received this free ebook from NetGalley in return for an honest review。EDITION Other Format ISBN 9780806542256PRICE $26。00 (USD) 。。。more

Tim Shaffer

What a great read。 For a non-fiction book it reads like fiction。 Full of details that really highlight the differences between the haves and have nots of the late 1890’s。 A real keeper。

Sydney

The narrative is confusing and too much time is spent on people other than the Hamiltons。 Just really boring。

Jessica Jones

Interesting read about the family of one of our founding fathers。 This book was a quick read and I chose to read it because of the Hamilton name。 But I couldn't put the book down because of all the family drama。 You need to read this book you won't regret it。 This goes to show that we all have ghosts in our closets from our family。 Interesting read about the family of one of our founding fathers。 This book was a quick read and I chose to read it because of the Hamilton name。 But I couldn't put the book down because of all the family drama。 You need to read this book you won't regret it。 This goes to show that we all have ghosts in our closets from our family。 。。。more

Ellen L

So much interesting history in this very wide ranging and engaging book that encompasses social, economic and cultural aspects of its time。 Enjoyed it very much。

Courtney

I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley。 All opinions are my own。 While Alexander Hamilton made his name as a Founding Father, I took for granted that his descendants would have a role in public life as well。 But to learn about the story of Robert and Eva, and their story involving a con and a mysterious death proves that sometimes truth truly is stranger than fiction。

M

3。5 starsA true crime case before true crime was a thing, and case reporting was in its infancy。 The public was immediately gripped showing society’s fascination with crime cases had been happening since the beginning。 After a day of socializing and drinking a woman stabs her friend what actually happened before, during, and after is a he said, she said, they said that gets played out in court。 To make things more interesting the whole thing involves the descendant of a founding father only stre 3。5 starsA true crime case before true crime was a thing, and case reporting was in its infancy。 The public was immediately gripped showing society’s fascination with crime cases had been happening since the beginning。 After a day of socializing and drinking a woman stabs her friend what actually happened before, during, and after is a he said, she said, they said that gets played out in court。 To make things more interesting the whole thing involves the descendant of a founding father only strengthening the public’s obsession with the case and all the drama surrounding it that involved for them just the murder including validity of her marriages, and paternity and even maternity of children。 Vintage true crime is one of my favorite things because the things people were allowed to say, do, and get away with always blows my mind。 This was really interesting and I liked watching all the court drama, and the events that followed play out。 *a copy of this book was provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review* 。。。more

Cheryl

I wasn't sure if I really wanted to read this book, but since this is the year I have decided to read anything, I picked it up。 I found that I thoroughly enjoyed it。 I even laughed out loud at some of the antics that went on during their relationship。 The writer did an excellent job of researching the time period and I found myself connecting the dots between other well known individuals that lived during the same time period。 I appreciated that。It was a fun read and I learned so much! I wasn't sure if I really wanted to read this book, but since this is the year I have decided to read anything, I picked it up。 I found that I thoroughly enjoyed it。 I even laughed out loud at some of the antics that went on during their relationship。 The writer did an excellent job of researching the time period and I found myself connecting the dots between other well known individuals that lived during the same time period。 I appreciated that。It was a fun read and I learned so much! 。。。more

Star Gater

When will I learn? Rhetorical。 The blurb says it all: Grifter, disgraced descendant, & tabloid journalism。 What's missing: numerous affairs, abortions, and pay-offs。 This was just okay for me。 I was disappointed that I didn't realize Scandalous was going to dominate in this fashion。 I expected some immortality mixed with dirty politics。 The narration was fine。 Thank you NetGalley and Tantor Audio for accepting my request to read and review The Scandalous Hamiltons。 When will I learn? Rhetorical。 The blurb says it all: Grifter, disgraced descendant, & tabloid journalism。 What's missing: numerous affairs, abortions, and pay-offs。 This was just okay for me。 I was disappointed that I didn't realize Scandalous was going to dominate in this fashion。 I expected some immortality mixed with dirty politics。 The narration was fine。 Thank you NetGalley and Tantor Audio for accepting my request to read and review The Scandalous Hamiltons。 。。。more

Kris10

This was a story too outrageous to be true。。。but was。 It would definitely make a great movie or possibly a tv series!! It was well written and a riot to read。 The book was a snapshot into the Gilded Age and how the posh rich lived and what they could get away from。。。or at least TRIED to get away with!! As they say, sometimes the truth is stranger than fiction!!

Allison Heckethorn

The Scandalous Hamiltons covers the trial and media representation of Eva Hamilton and Robert Ray Hamilton。 This book covers con artistry, stabbings, divorce and tragedy through the eyes of the journalism of that time。The author described the characters such flourish, and one could picture this book in a current true-crime documentary as the pages unfold。 An in-depth look at the support characters add to the depth of the story。 I was intrigued throughout。 Much like a modern day celebrity court t The Scandalous Hamiltons covers the trial and media representation of Eva Hamilton and Robert Ray Hamilton。 This book covers con artistry, stabbings, divorce and tragedy through the eyes of the journalism of that time。The author described the characters such flourish, and one could picture this book in a current true-crime documentary as the pages unfold。 An in-depth look at the support characters add to the depth of the story。 I was intrigued throughout。 Much like a modern day celebrity court trial, the salacious findings of the trial gave a glimpse of the American elite。While I found myself searching the Internet for pictures of the characters and places, I think this book could improve with historical pictures/references to help the reader familiarize themselves with the characters and historical places。Fans of modern intrigue along with historical buffs can all find something enjoyable in these chapters。 Overall a fun and intriguing read。 。。。more

Amy

I tend to read a lot of historical fiction, so decided to take this small detour and listen to something that was historical nonfiction。 It wasn’t really a leap, as this tale was as full of drama and intrigue as its fictional counterparts! I found the story interesting, not just the information about this generation of Hamiltons, which I did not know, but also the history about the rise of tabloid journalism。 The one thing I was not fond of was the narrator。 His voice was quite monotonous and he I tend to read a lot of historical fiction, so decided to take this small detour and listen to something that was historical nonfiction。 It wasn’t really a leap, as this tale was as full of drama and intrigue as its fictional counterparts! I found the story interesting, not just the information about this generation of Hamiltons, which I did not know, but also the history about the rise of tabloid journalism。 The one thing I was not fond of was the narrator。 His voice was quite monotonous and he sounded bored 90% of the time。 It reminded me of when my grandfather used to read newspaper articles to me。 It almost sounded like he was just trying too hard to sound “serious。”Thank you to #NetGalley and #TantorAudio for the ALC in exchange for my honest opinions。 3。5 stars 。。。more